The Strange Death of Mistress Coffin Read online

  The Strange Death of Mistress Coffin

  For Linda

  The Strange Death of Mistress Coffin

  a mystery

  Robert J. Begiebing

  University Press of New England

  Hanover and London

  University Press of New England

  www.upne.com

  © 1991 Robert J. Begiebing

  All rights reserved

  ISBN 978-1-61168-339-4 (e-book)

  For permission to reproduce any of the material in this book, contact Permissions, University Press of New England, One Court Street, Suite 250, Lebanon NH 03766; or visit www.upne.com

  This book was first published in 1996 by Algonquin Books of Chapel Hill.

  I would like to thank four good friends whose encouragement and advice helped me to change the direction of my life and write this novel: Bob Hoddeson, Loftus Jestin, Lawrence Kinsman, and Wesley McNair.

  The wife of one Willi[x] of Exeter was found in the river dead, her neck broken, her tongue black and swollen out of her mouth, and the blood settled in her, the privy parts swollen, etc., as if she had been much abused . . .

  —The Journal of Governor John Winthrop of Massachusetts, 1648

  The Strange Death of Mistress Coffin

  Prologue

  TO RICHARD BROWNE, ESQ.,

  at the Sign of the Red Pony,

  Salem.

  SIR—

  It was a most signal pleasure to regain the acquaintance of so able a young man who proposes to venture among us in this New England, a wilderness of riches sufficient to enable you to restore that portion of your patrimony which agents of your late father have so lamentably squandered. And though it was a great sorrow to learn of the death of my old friend and distinguished associate, yet I came away in the firm hope that his son might choose to cast his lot with us. Upon certain inquiries into the especial advantages just now of our Pascataqua region for the forest trade, I can report not only abundant opportunities for a young man of parts, but an occasion of some urgency that doubtless shall be the foundation of your engagement with our plantation, of the settlement upon you of such lands as those we discussed, and of your credible entrance into the forest trade. In brief, you shall have the occasion to mark your distinction among us. Just as I saw upon our meeting in Salem on the twelfth day of last month that you, like your father, have grown into manhood with a quick and compassionative mind, so do I hold in high confidence your uncommon capacity and your occupation in the Inns of Court; for your familiarity with instruments and courtesies of the law equips you for such an errand as I have in mind and promises such welcome and excellent assistance as that which, I do freely confess, I just now stand so in need.

  I refer to an incident that came to pass last spring, but the effects of which still linger among us, viz., the strange death of a local woman, Mistress Coffin, whose body was found after long search in the waters of our great inland bay. She had been stripped of every shred of clothing and tormented in a most unspeakable manner. We have been unable to gain an exact view of what occurred or who was the instrument of such violence. Our desire for resolution to this outrage has met with bitter disappointment. The dead woman’s husband, you see, mysteriously withdrew his action against the man deemed likely to be responsible, directly or indirectly, for the poor creature’s demise, one Jared Higgins. More, there was a certain lack of demonstration and thereupon the Courts and magistrates became otherwise occupied. Hence it is that litigation has insufficiently advanced, nay has entirely vanished. As a magistrate, however, my personal interest in justice concerning these events has rejuvenated, particularly in consideration of certain late occurrences. Jared Higgins has disappeared, his wife lives in a dark web of afflictions from causes unknown, and some are roused to fear and anger as much by the incapacity of the Court to assign guilt as by lingering circumstances that issue from the woman’s death.

  Our foremost concern will be the afflicted woman, Elizabeth Higgins. We must uncover the source of her torments and assuage them, and throw light upon the strange disappearance of her husband. Then perchance we may search the death of Mistress Coffin to its truest source.

  It would seem but dark ambage were I to belabor the myriad details in this epistle. I shall tell you what we have uncovered when we next meet, and Goody Higgins shall relate her trials and situation to you herself. Can you lay down your affairs and come away directly?

  Now as to the merits of life in our plantation, several of which I touched upon when we met, I doubt not that you have discovered by your sojourn in the Bay Colony even unto this day the wealth that awaits those who would labor in this wilderness, far removed from the amenity of Mother England. If more bereft of comfort even than certain of those settlements through which you have passed since your landing at Boston, our small plantation, I assure you, is most excellently situated, well above the mouth of the Merrimac, upon the fish-laden river at Robinson’s Falls which contributes to our great inland bay and, ultimately, the fine harbor at Strawberry Banke. We are merely a journey of a day or two, first by ship out of Boston or Salem and then by boat up into the bay and river. You need but hire your passage upon your arrival at the Banke and the boatmen will deliver you to us.

  We boast the advantages of the most flourishing plantation of the Pascataqua, a region if remote yet furnished with good woods, springs, rivers, fish, fowl, game, fruit, the nearby multitudinous seas and commodious bays, harbors, and islands. The seaport, hardly a half-day’s journey by water, thrives and cannot but continue to prosper in future Atlantic trade. The great pine dominates our forest, yet are there plentiful maple, ash, oak and other choice woods to increase the gathering trade in lumber, staves, and naval stores. To the rising prosperity of our plantation at the Falls let me recommend to you likewise the orderliness of our community itself—founded as it was by learned men of God who established laws, magistrates, and church from the outset—that might well serve as exemplar to less fortunate settlements in our region. Found to be within the patent and choosing to become allied with so prosperous and successful a benefactor, we, moreover, have lately come under the additional protection and regulation of Massachusetts Bay.

  I shall not adventure to make this epistle any longer than to say how much I enjoyed all your news of England and have related these same to Mistress Cole, who even now remains struck by wonder. She sends you most affectionate greetings and lives in high anticipation of your likely arrival. She craves to speak further of news from Mother England, and to see again the son of one so cherished, a son now in the flower of his manhood but who, upon our last seeing him, was barely more than a child. Do say you will come to assist us.

  Awaiting your reply, I remain, Sir, your affectionate servant,

  JONATHAN COLE Robinson’s Falls, October 10 1648

  Part I

  Stay not among the wicked

  Lest that with them you perish,

  But let us to New England go,

  And the Pagan People cherish.

  —Song, “Invitation to

  New Plantation,” 1638

  I

  “There is a man in town,” Elizabeth Higgins said. She was watching Richard Browne carefully. “I do not think an Englishman by birth. Mr. Coffin, or so he is called. Last May, he hired my husband to convey Mistress Coffin in his canoe to Dover market.”

  “I do not know that settlement well,” Richard Browne said.

  “There’s a large market there in early summer, by Third River. Some dozen miles from where we sit. She had been trading cattle, and other things. When her affairs were settled, she returned to the landing, or so it was said by one, and could not find my husband
, Jared. Although he had said he looked for her! The hour grew late; he finally returned home.”

  “Was your husband not alarmed?”

  “Of course! He went to Mr. Coffin. The man grew distracted, made accusations, raised a search party. It was later he finally laid charges. As a first step against my husband’s breaking contract. Victory would have brought more serious accusations to the higher court. If she were forced overland, there were those who knew she carried on her some Indian wheat seed and other currency.”

  A four-foot back log settled in the fire. Elizabeth Higgins rose, moved farther to one side and opposite certain trivets and skillets and braziers standing on their spindling legs, and then adjusted the logs with a hay fork that had been leaning in the corner.

  “And she never returned home,” Browne stated.

  “That’s so. They finally found her ill-used body in the water. Whoever it was took more than her kernels and coin.” She paused. The fire boomed from its adjustment and the wind at the chimney. “Pray spare me describing,” she said. “Thus do our first parents bring calamities upon us.”

  He nodded, then said: “And thus we add unto them by cruelty in our own persons.”

  She looked narrowly at him. “Her husband was, I say, outraged. In all the back and forth, Jared made it clear that here was a woman to find her own trouble—I don’t know just what he told them. Then Mr. Coffin added ‘raising an evil report’ to his list of charges.” Elizabeth Higgins stopped and looked down.

  “She was, in truth, a high-spirited woman,” she finally continued. “Clever, more fond than her husband of trade and town affairs. And loose-tongued, Mr. Browne.”

  “I don’t see why the unfortunate man would not pursue the satisfaction of saving his murdered wife’s name, at least,” Browne said, as if to himself.

  “Perhaps he received satisfaction otherwise. Jared had done nothing. This man has powers others do not. Who can say where they end? He is respected for much learning.” He saw hatred in her eyes. “The Devil will pick his bones!”

  “Do you charge him, Goody Higgins, with maleficium?”

  “I am tormented, Sir.”

  “Tormented?”

  She paused to test Browne’s eyes again, then added: “And signs. You might think me crazed if I speak everything.”

  He waited.

  “Here’s one then.” She seemed suddenly defiant. “One night a strange animal—one I had not seen before but like a rat—got into the house and woke me. Its movement was sluggish. But its eyes shone hideous by the fire, and it had rows of terrible little sharp teeth. I dared not go near but woke young Jared, who after much effort drove it out. Since that night we have sweet bays by the door stoop.”

  “Your torments are by this man’s hand or word?”

  “Can you not see it, Sir?”

  “You believe his ways darker than the Court. By what do you justify this belief?”

  “The loss of my husband! Illness of children! Blasted fields! Do not such things justify?” She nearly spat out her list of injuries.

  “Not always in themselves,” he said calmly. “God’s hand is at times ferocious.”

  “Yes, God’s invincible fire may scourge any of us, Mr. Browne.” She seemed near tears. “But I can only tell you, and Mr. Cole, my beliefs. I have seen and felt things no Christian woman should. My husband and many others the magistrates examined. But the proceedings are hidden.”

  Browne got up out of his chair and walked about the room. “The Lord too fires upon us, as you say. And there may be danger in assuming malignancy. Moreover, are not malignant persons His agents too, sent to try us, when He but loosens the chains? I wish to discover what is hidden, Goody Higgins, and by such pursuit to aid you. If as you say I discover some black corruption, so be it. But we must divide the day from the night.”

  She made no reply. He paced, looking at her from time to time. Noticing now also the shelves displaying her pewter and other ware, catching half-consciously the flicker of light off the brighter pots and kettles, the warming pan, the whitewashed walls between the brown timbers, he thought that despite her torment she managed to keep her house in order, the floors well sanded and scrubbed. In the corner beside the shelves stood her washbench, her broom, some large wooden tubs and three baskets. In the shadows there seemed to be other implements of housewifery. Only the woman herself appeared disordered.

  Was she beginning to trust him finally? Her resistance, her suspicion, seemed to be slackening. They had been wary of him, this woman and her son, from the very moment of his arrival.

  He compared her willingness to talk now to an hour ago when he had arrived with Mr. Cole—a selectman and a magistrate, now under the General Court of Massachusetts—at her small gambrel-roofed house by the river. The boy had opened the rough door just wide enough to peer out with both eyes and hold a firebrand toward the faces of the snow-covered intruders. At Mr. Cole’s voice, the boy opened the door and they stepped in quickly against the storm. The woman, sitting directly before a voluminous fire, rose, placed some sewing work on the settle, and turned toward them without speaking.

  He had not been able to see her clearly by the light of the fire and two knotty slices of burning candlewood held low in the wall, their smoke rising slowly into the chimney. She pulled the bedrug, draped over her shoulders, around her apron and skirts.

  But Cole, a large forceful man who dominated a room or a conversation, immediately introduced Browne as “the newcomer we spoke of, who has come to help.”

  Then she and Browne nodded at one another and the boy, perhaps fourteen, moved closer to his mother. The brand he held illuminated her face, and Browne noticed that her pale, probably hazel, eyes were vivid, yet her face was that of a woman who had gone without sleep, or had passed a dangerous travail. Her erect body did not conceal her fatigue. As Cole spoke with her of the storm, the state of her cordwood, the town’s desire for a minister, Browne watched her. In a better moment, she might be a striking woman, he thought. She was perhaps thirty-one or two.

  “It’s all right, Jared,” she had said to the boy as Cole made ready to leave. “You go to sleep now.”

  Browne now looked at Elizabeth Higgins again. “It must be very late,” he said. “You need to rest, Goody Higgins.”

  “Sleep is a stranger to me.” She began reciting from the Psalm: “‘I am weary with my groaning, all night make I my bed to swim: I water my couch with tears.’”

  He took up some further lines to encourage her: “‘Let all mine enemies be ashamed and sore vexed: let them return and be ashamed suddenly!’”

  She looked up at him, her face now like one returning from the dullness of sleep.

  “I’ll stop awhile if that would help,” he said. “I can spend the time until daylight watching in that chair.” He smiled. “You’ve given me much to think on.”

  “You will help me?”

  “I will look into these matters. I will do everything I can to discover your husband and put your sufferings to rest. I am disquieted by these events, as is Mr. Cole. Why not sleep now, Goody Higgins, and let me wake?”

  She had asked at first, before he had removed his great cloak, if he were to be their minister. But he had explained that he was called not by the Lord but by Mr. Cole, as an assistant in a certain Higgins-Coffin matter.

  Then he added: “I am not a dissenter after the good Lincolnshire folk who settled here when the Synod banished Mr. Robinson and others.” She had said nothing, so he continued. “I came over later to see after my father’s ventures, which turned to losses.”

  “And just how is it Mr. Cole believes you may help, Sir?”

  “I believe I may.”

  She looked unsatisfied. He continued: “I never took my degree at Cambridge, but went to Lincoln’s Inn. Nor did I stay long enough to be called to the bar. Mr. Cole believes, however, that I might be of use here in divers ways, as I had been briefly at Salem. And to you.”

  “So you are among us now,” she said
. “You will not be asked to leave with such a protector as Mr. Cole.” She stopped as if resting a moment. The glow of the fire fluttered over her face. “He has smoothed your way, Sir, just as he hopes you shall smooth mine.” She looked him over and he quietly bore her scrutiny.

  Must she not, he thought, see that he was a man of substance? His manner, after all, was gentle. His plum waistcoat and suit of full leather breeches, his indigo doublet lined with silken cloth and much brightly slashed cutwork must, he assumed, reassure her. He noticed her eyes on his embroidered gloves, which he had removed and placed in his lap. And did not his age speak to her in his favor as well? After all, unlike Mr. Cole he was of her own generation, conceivably her very age.

  It was then that he had asked her whether she might tell him of her present troubles.

  Now she was getting up and unwrapping the bedrug from around her. She placed it on the settle and looked at Browne.

  “You have provisions for this season?” he asked.

  “Yes. Some from planting grounds untouched, some in trade.” She glanced upwards toward a single small chamber above. “Some bushels of grain, barley, and rye. Peas and beans as well. And some Indian wheat.” She glanced toward the north end of the kitchen area at a small door. “And several flitches of bacon; there is cheese, cider, and butter in the dairy house.” She sighed, as if the further words had fatigued her completely.

  “Good then,” Browne said. “This is all most curious. That seat by the fire will comfort me while I think. You join your children now in sleep yourself. I’ll be just here.”

  She settled some coals into a bright warming pan, saying as if speaking to herself: “Jared and I laid a fire in the other room this night.” Then she turned and walked toward the open entryway to the only other room, or parlor, at ground level. At the threshold she turned again to Browne slowly, like one sleepwalking, and said: “I am very thankful, Mr. Browne; just now I need to sleep.”